Notes on Modernization

Day of the Dead

Day of the Dead Celebration in Sumpango, Guatemala Photo credit: Susan Randall.

blue bar

Here are the notes that I used in my short video.

Modernization

One definition: the transformation from a traditional, rural, agrarian society to a secular, urban, industrial society

Period of time from 1600 to 1900 in Western Europe and America; slightly later elsewhere in the Western world

Creation and development of a middle class

Political modernization and some form of representative democracy

Economic shift

Religious influence decreases

City/suburban life

Education

Focus on individual

Value laden and adoption of western cultures

Let's see, what would I add to my video remarks?

1st, I would emphasize that the idea of modernization was originally developed in an American/West European context to explain development in the world. This, there was a heavy connotation that the path followed by these countries was the developmental path to be followed by all countries.

2nd, naturally, as part of the decolonization wave of the post-1945 period, it was natural that many non-Western intellectuals developed alternate narratives that explained how development (modernization) was to occur. Some of there thinkers/politicians became leaders of the non-aligned movement, but the critique of modernization involved more than just a discussion of how to fit between Soviet and American spheres of influence or alliance.

3rd, and I have warned of this in the video, there is a negative connotation to naming a society a "pre-modern" society or a "not yet modern" society or a culture with "vestiges of the pre-modern," as if being modern is having achieved perfection in socio-economic development. There is so much of an idea of "good" wound up tightly in "modern."

4th, I frankly do not have a strong enough sociological, anthropological or economic theory background to critique modernization on a scientific basis, but I am sure that has been done.

5th, finally, at the same time, there is something useful about the idea of characterizing the socio-economic development of a society even if we apply the term modernization to that process.

Some recommended online lectures and websites