De-Industrialization Assignment

Slatington Quarry
Photo credit C.T. Evans

Just a hundred years ago, the landscape of the United States was much different. Then, the country was in the midst of a sweeping industrial development that would make the United States the most industrialized country in the world. The United States was filled with industrial plants, factories and mines; they were everywhere. For example, the immediate area around my hometown of Slatington in eastern Pennsylvania was filled with slate quarries. There were dozens of them producing slate for roofs and for school blackboards. The town also had an iron works, textile or sewing mills, a gas works, brewery, umbrella factory and more. (The images are clickable for a larger size.)

Quarry Ruins
Photo credit C.T. Evans

If you were to walk the area around Slatington today, as I have done, you will find little that remains of the town's once thriving industrial past--You've got to be careful when you take such a walk because much of the land is private property and some of it is actually a little on the dangerous side. What remains, besides the piles of discarded waste slate, are some piled slate where the cranes and buildings once stood. All of the buildings--most of which were rather ramshackle wooden structures--have disappeared. You might find some cable moorings left in the ground where the derrick structures were anchored, but that is about it. There are also big holes in the ground that are now filled with water. These were the quarries of a century ago from where the slate was blasted out. These quarries and mounds of slate are the ruins of this country's industrial age.

 

Quarry
Photo credit C.T. Evans

If we move north three miles up the road from from Slatington to Palmerton, then we can see another example of the crumbling of the once mighty industrial infrastructure of the United States. Now there is very little left of the former New Jersey Zinc factory west plant in Palmerton; the east plant, in the same town, is still working.

 

Zinc Plant
Photo credit Library of Congress

At its height, the Zinc factory employed thousands and thousands of men and women--in fact, you might call the town a typical factory town as it was named after the president of the Zinc factory, Stephen Palmer. While Slatington was a "slate" town; Palmerton was a "zinc" town; and Bethlehem, home to Bethlehem Steel, was a "steel," etc. Early in the twentieth century, the company located its smelting operation in Palmerton to take advantage of the easy availability of coal from eastern Pennsylvania and zinc ore from northern New Jersey. The Zinc factory went right on working through the Great Depression, World War II and the Cold War. My grandfather, uncles and cousins all worked there at different times. Now large parts of the west plant, which once spanned over thirty buildings on some two hundred acres, are crumbling, and actually not all that much really remains except a building or two and some heaps of slag.

Zinc plant Ruins
Photo credit road_less_trvled

The Palmerton Zinc Company site is now a superfund cleanup site, monitored by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). The north slope of Blue Mountain, seen in the background on this photo, is pretty much a barren wasteland because of the heavy emissions of lead, cadmium and sulfuric acid from the factory over a time span of at least eighty years. In addition, the company deposited millions and millions of tons of waste slag at the site, which also released hazardous substances into the environment, especially the water. At the company's east plant there is a huge cinder bank, 2.5 miles long, 200 feet high and anywhere between 500 to 1,000 feet wide (USEPA 2005). In the town, the residents and their houses and yards have been tested for abnormal levels of lead and cadmium. For some residences, they had the benefit of the ground in their yards being replaced. Growing up it was always understood that nothing but some moss would grow in my aunt's yard in Palmerton--no grass. No one ever thought of the environmental costs associated with the industrialization of the country.

Blue bar

I cover the topic of industrialization in HIS 102 and HIS 112, but what happens after "industrialization" also interests me, and that means the process of de-industrialization--not surprisingly there is a wiki entry. There seem to be different definitions of just what exactly de-industrialization is, but to me it means the shift in the economy from manufacturing oriented to a service economy--to further complicated matters, you could say the shift from modernization to post-modern. I would also say that de-industrialization means the dismantling of the industrial infrastructure, and that dismantling often simply takes the form of abandonment of facilities to natural ruin. That's why I also call this the industrial ruins paper.

At one time if you had grown up in the United States, you would have been exposed to factory life. Factories were everywhere, part of the industrial might that began to develop in America in the late nineteenth century and that culminated in the massive industrial production of World War II. But, through the 1970s and 1980s, and for many different economic reasons, the economy of the United States shifted away from its manufacturing base, and one after another major industrial facilities shut their doors. In many places now, these are ruins, but the question remains, what should be done with those sites? See what Paul Carpenter has to say in the first few paragraphs of his article, Bethlehem Steel history may be obliterated in Lackawanna, N.Y.

I have looked for different statistics to illustrate the shift of the US economy away from industrial-centered. This chart (Sectors of US Economy as Percent of GDP 1947-2009) clearly shows that since 1950, the percentage of the economy devoted to manufacturing has dropped from about 28% to about 12%. Mining seems to have stayed 3-4%. Checking statistics on iron and steel productions, which are a little difficult to decipher,

Iron and Steel Production in the United States
1950 1970 1990 2009
58,500,000 metric tons iron production
87,800,000 metric tons raw steel production
146,300,000 metric tons total production
 82,800,000
119,000,000
201,800,000 total		 49,700,000
89,700,000
139,400,000 total		 19,000,000
59,400,000
78,400,000 total
Industrial Employment in the United States
1950 1970 1990 2009
13,161,000 (8.7% of the total population of 152 million) 18,424,000 (8.9% of the total population of 205 million) 17,796,000 (7.1% of the total population of 249 million) 12,556,000 (4.1% of the total population of 308 million)

Sources: National Population Estimates, Employment, Hours, and Earnings from the Current Employment Statistics
survey (National) Series Id: CES3000000001; Iron and Steel Statistics, US Geological Society (2010)

Here are some useful websites that you will want to look at for images of industrial ruins:

Since I am interested in this location, I am also listing some materials in reference to the Environmental Protection Agency's superfund zinc cleanup in Palmerton.

Watch my video remarks on this assignment (also available on ITunesU).

Here are examples of this paper,

Here is your assignment:

Write a two-page paper (maybe three if you have photos) in which you focus on some aspect of de-industrialization either in the United States or in Western Europe. I am being purposefully vague here with the phrasing of the assignment. There are many different ways that you can approach this paper, but essentially I do not want you to focus on the costs and benefits of the industrial revolution as it was occurring, but instead I want you to think about the remnants and remains of the industrial revolution today. What should be done with these sites? Why are these factories no longer in operation? What about all those years of turning out industrial products, and all the men and women who worked in these plants? Who should bear the clean up costs? Should these sites be cleaned up? Should they become monuments, or should they just be razed and redeveloped? These are just some questions that come to my mind. So, there are many different ways that you can approach writing this paper, but I suggest you do try to be creative. Notice how quickly the present becomes the past and is forgotten or abandoned.

Here are the formal requirements for your paper:

Your assignment should be submitted on Canvas.